Navigating the HR Dilemma: Enhancing Employee Trust and Engagement

(3 min read)

The role of Human Resources (HR) in fostering a positive workplace culture is more critical than ever. A recent report by MyPerfectResume highlights a startling trend: 86% of workers fear their HR representatives, and 85% hesitate to discuss work-related issues with them. These findings indicate a pressing need for companies to re-evaluate their HR practices and communications to better align with employee expectations and organizational goals.

Understanding the Core Issues

The report identifies several key HR areas where employees are concerned:

  • Confidentiality: 37% of employees doubt HR’s ability to maintain confidentiality.
  • Fear of Repercussions: 31% fear negative consequences from raising issues.
  • Perceived Ineffectiveness: 37% believe HR is ineffective in resolving their problems.
  • Preference for Direct Solutions: 31% prefer addressing issues on their own or with their manager.
  • Uncertainty: 20% are unsure of HR’s response.

These concerns are compounded by opportunities to improve perceptions of HR’s role within the organization:

  • Office Politics: 71% feel HR is overly involved in office politics.
  • Procedure Over People: 68% believe HR prioritizes procedures over employee welfare.
  • Lack of Responsiveness: 67% find it challenging to get timely responses from HR.

Strategic Responses for HR Enhancement

To address these issues, HR departments have an opportunity to evolve and prioritize employee trust and engagement. Here are actionable strategies:

  1. Enhance Confidentiality: Implement robust data protection measures and clear policies to reassure employees that their concerns will be handled discreetly.
  2. Improve Communication: Establish regular, open lines of communication between HR and employees to build trust and transparency.
  3. Increase Responsiveness: Streamline HR processes to ensure timely responses to employee queries and issues.
  4. Focus on People: Shift the emphasis from rigid procedures to personalized employee support, ensuring that HR is seen as an ally rather than a bureaucratic hurdle.
  5. Expand HR Capacity: Advocate for increased HR staffing to allow for more dedicated attention to employee needs, especially in smaller organizations.

Celebrating the Importance of HR

HR professionals are the backbone of any organization, playing a pivotal role in nurturing a positive work environment, fostering employee engagement, and driving organizational success. They are often the unsung heroes who handle a multitude of responsibilities, from recruitment and onboarding to employee relations and compliance.

HR’s impact on employee well-being and organizational culture cannot be overstated. By championing employee development, creating inclusive workplaces, and ensuring fair and consistent practices, HR professionals help build a foundation of trust and respect. Their efforts lead to increased employee satisfaction, lower turnover rates, and ultimately, a more productive and harmonious workplace.

Supporting HR Professionals

HR professionals are often stretched too thin, burned out, and feel unsupported by the C-suite. According to the 2023-2024 SHRM State of the Workplace report, 45% of HR professionals report feeling overwhelmed by their workload, and 40% feel unsupported by senior management. Addressing these challenges can create an environment where HR can thrive and better serve employees..

The Executive’s Role in HR Enhancement

While HR plays a pivotal role, executives and senior management must also be involved in driving these changes. This includes providing the necessary resources, supporting HR initiatives, and fostering a company culture that values and respects employee contributions.

Call to Action: Learning & Development with Scott Foster

Empowering Leadership and Wellbeing: Thriving in Today's Landscape

Book Scott Foster for an inspiring and transformative session designed to empower leaders and enhance wellbeing. Delve into the powerful intersection of leadership and wellbeing, essential for navigating challenges successfully.

Discover the secrets of effective leadership and proactive strategies to steer you towards unprecedented success by cultivating a culture of growth and well-being. Through interactive discussions, real-world examples, and the sharing of best practices, Scott Foster will help you prioritize key areas that will shape your path to prosperity.  Follow these links to book Scott or to learn more.  

Final Thoughts

Addressing the perceptions of HR is not just about focusing on a department—it’s about enhancing the overall organizational culture. By taking these steps, companies can improve morale, increase job satisfaction, reduce turnover, and create a more aligned and motivated workforce.

For further reading on this topic, consider these sources:

Optimizing HR is a journey, but with the right strategies and commitment, it’s a journey that will lead to a more engaged and productive workforce.


Scott Foster is CEO of Wellco. Scott is a frequently-invited expert and speaker regarding well-being, engagement, & leadership.  Wellco provides award-winning solutions to measurably improve health experiences & outcomes. For more information, contact Wellco. 

Rave Reviews 

How does one of the best companies to work for take charge of employee health risks and costs? Wellco’s systems are the foundation to our innovative program and extraordinary outcomes. Wellco’s HealthHammer is the best and most powerful health management system on the Planet!

Larry Gaynor President & CEO, TNG Worldwide

Scott is an engaging speaker that connects well with attendees. He invests time and effort into fully understanding who his audience will be and designs content that is relevant and impactful. I have been hiring speakers for many years and Scott is the only I have hired more than 3 times!

Shawn Premer Chief Human Resources Officer, Consumers Credit Union

Permission to Reprint
You may reprint any items from this blog in your own print or electronic newsletter. When you do, please include the following paragraph: Reprinted from Wellco. Free, proven healthcare & leadership market intelligence from Scott Foster, Wellco CEO.  Learn more at Copyright (c) by Wellco.